My first Crossfit Class

I’m going to start this blog off by saying that what works for me may not necessarily work for other people, and vice versa.

Okay, so let’s get down to business. I’ve been curious about Crossfit for forever. Everyone I’ve talked to said it’s kind of like a fitness cult. If there would be any cult that I would join, it would probably be a fitness one. So, when a Groupon for a one month membership to Crossfit showed up in my inbox I jumped on that sucker like kids in a bouncy house.

I knew within the first five minutes that it was not my bag, mainly because the class instructor kept insisting that I could do something that I couldn’t. I’m sure I’ve mentioned this, but I have seriously jacked-up hips, I’m not sure if they came from my years of dancing or if they were just exacerbated by them, but my hips are kind of aligned wrong which really only bothers me when asked to do certain types of squats—my hips literally just don’t function like other people’s’ in this particular motion. We spent five minutes in one of those types of squats, and when I told the instructor my reason for not being able to do the squat correctly he said something along the lines of, “You have to do it.” I’m sure it sounded like an excuse to him, but I’m of the school of “People know their bodies a lot better than you do.” If years of physical therapy couldn’t get me to do it, I doubt an hour of lifting can. Needless to say I started off the class hating this guy.

Next came clean and press with barbells, which was fine by me, because I happen to have decent upper body strength. I was, however, partnered with someone who had to weigh forty pounds less than I do, was a head shorter, and of a much slighter build naturally.  I’m not saying I’m a huge muscle man here, but I would guess that in a normal gym type setting we would probably not be lifting the same weight.   There was no accounting for personal strength, build or fitness aptitude, women pressed one amount, men another.

After that we loaded up a barbell and carried it, one hand per person down the block and back—now this is the exercise that bugged me more than all the others, because it pretty much screamed out for bad form, rows of people leaning to one side and putting all the pressure of the barbell on their lower back and hip joint, not to mention disproportionate strain in the forearm muscles.

After that came push ups, sit ups, and pull-ups—standard fare. I will say that I saw a lot of people using momentum in their pull-ups, swinging their body to create the kind of force that naturally drives the body upwards. That’s less of a pull-up and more of a swing-up.

Is the class hard, there’s no doubt and I absolutely see why people get into it.

Is it for me, not so much. I really wanted to go to class and be a total convert, but mostly I just felt like I was in bad form boot camp. Of course, it’s very possible that other Crossfit classes and centers aren’t like this, but first impressions count and my first impression wasn’t all that great.

I have a month of classes left and now I’m wondering whether to let them go to waste or give this class another shot.

Have you tried Crossfit? What was your experience?

Kim

Comments

  1. That sounds like a pretty awful experience. My personal thoughts on crossfit are similar. I haven’t tried it, but I don’t like being ordered to do things so I am pretty sure I’d hate it. It looks like actual bootcamp to me and I never had any desire to go into the military. I have watched videos with the tire pushing and pulling competitions and the ropes and chains and well, none of it looks fun to me and I like my fitness to be fun whenever possible. Hence dance classes, circus aeria/trapeze classes and simple things like jogging or doing turbo jam at home. ;-) I hate to waste my groupons too so I feel your dilemn

    [Reply]

  2. Dilemma. Sorry, I pushed send too soon!

    [Reply]

  3. I’ve never tried CrossFit, but like you, have heard rave reviews from converts. It’s disconcerting to hear about poor form and your interaction with the instructor. Maybe he just thought you needed the boost. I’d say to give it another shot but to go to a different class. Maybe you’ll be surprised. It would be a shame for those classes to go to waste!

    [Reply]

  4. As someone who also has hip issues I totally get the frustration. I once had an instructor try to push me down into the right position. I ended up on the floor and her supervisor came to the pool deck to apologize profusely and say that something like that would never happen again.

    Maybe you can swap it for something else at the place? or is it just a crossfit place?

    [Reply]

  5. Ack! I’m so sorry you had that kind of experience with CrossFit. My husband runs a CrossFit gym and hearing that about your coach would break his heart. Our coaches take pride in keeping people safe. We practice every lift with PVC before using weight, even if you’ve done it a hundred times. And everything is scalable. If that kind of squat didn’t work for you the coach should have said, you know what, how about you work on x instead. It just sounds like it was a miss with quality coaching. Bummer.
    Best wishes! -Les

    [Reply]

  6. This is so interesting! A friend of mine who has struggled with her weight for a long time tried Crossfit recently and had a similar experience with a trainer that was a total turnoff from the start (and had her in tears after the class :( ). They flat out told her that she should just sit and watch while the rest of the class did an exercise that she wasn’t able to do because of her weight/inexperience…no offer to modify or of an alternative that would work the same/similar muscles. Totally the OPPOSITE of what you expect from a good personal trainer/fitness instructor!

    I know a number of folks that really love Crossfit, and have sworn up and down that the trainers at their gym would never do something like that and she should try a different location. I guess there’s always going to be a bad apple somewhere and unfortunately you guys found a few, but it certainly doesn’t make me want to try it after hearing about experiences like this!

    [Reply]

  7. Wow! I guess instructors come in all types. I love my crossfit class-all the instructors are really wonderful and aware of other limitations. We do lots of modifications for injury and age in my class–and everyone just works to their level. I have never had anyone yell at me or seen anyone cry—unless it was yelling to great job and we were crying at the end from pure joy the workout was done. I agree with Sarah G–bad class. Come to Wyoming and you will love Crossfit!

    This does make me nervous to drop into a WOD in a different town when I am traveling, though.

    [Reply]

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: